Thursday, May 12, 2022

The Critical Thinker by Steven Schuster

 

Chapter 1: What is Critical Thinking?

This is a good beginner level book about critical thinking. It is easy enough for anyone to understand, even without any prior studies of critical thinking or logic. Actually, this book doesn’t cover logic at all, but it does discuss some of the basic principles that can help people think better.

One of the important tips from this chapter is SLOW DOWN! Critical thinking is not hasty.

But why do we have to slow our thinking down? What are we slowing down FOR? The answer is, we have to slow down so we can ask ourselves key questions about our beliefs. Questions like: “WHY do you believe that?” or “HOW do you know that?”

This chapter reminds us that the very heart and soul of good thinking involves taking the time to figure out WHY we believe the things we believe. If we don’t do that, we’re not really thinking at all, are we? When we start doing that, we will be taking the first steps on the path to becoming really good critical thinkers.

Chapter 2: “What are the Main Guidelines of Critical Thinking?”

One of the important tips from this chapter is to avoid OVER-GENERALIZATIONS! The whole point of critical thinking is to distinguish what is true, or likely to be true, from what is false, or likely to be false. The problem with over-generalizations is that they are almost always false, so people who use over-generalizations are extremely unlikely to be good critical thinkers.

If you make claims about EVERY member of huge and varied groups like “all Americans” or “all Russians” or “all Democrats” or “all Republicans” or “all Men” or “all Women” or, worst of all “EVERYONE” then you are almost certainly making a false statement, or, at the very least, an unprovable statement. If you use false statements as premises for logical arguments then your argument is automatically going to fail because a sound argument cannot be based on a false premise. If you use an unprovable statement as a premise for an argument than your argument is not going to be very persuasive.

Suppose someone says “anyone who enters the US illegally should be in jail.” If you ask them why they think that, they might reply with an over-generalization like “EVERYONE who breaks the law should be in jail.”

The problem with this over-generalization is that it is almost certainly not true and the person who makes it almost certainly doesn’t even believe it. If we ask them “In 19th century America a person who broke the law requiring them to return a runaway slave should have gone to jail?” Or “In Nazi Germany a person who refused to turn in a Jew so he or she could be sent to a concentration camp should have been sent to jail?” they will probably say “No. I only mean people who break GOOD laws should be in jail.”

Notice that the over-generalization was a sloppy and careless effort to AVOID critical thinking. Once we get to a statement that only people who break GOOD laws should be in jail then we can start some hard critical thinking about what is the definition of a good law and how can we distinguish good laws from bad laws.

We might further ask “Should people who roll through a stop sign be in jail because they broke the law?” Or “Should a hungry old person with no money who steals a piece of bread go to jail?” Most people would probably say “no” to both of these questions which might lead us to modify their initial over-generalization again to something like “Everyone who breaks a GOOD law that is about a SERIOUS issue should go to jail BUT we can also make exceptions for people who break a relatively minor law because they are in desperate need.”

Now again we can do some real critical thinking about what are the serious issues that we should jail people for and what are minor issues that we should not jail people for and what could count as desperate need that would allow us to show mercy to someone who broke the law.

In this example the initial over-generalization was an attempt to avoid thinking about all these important questions. In fact, over-generalizations are often attempts to avoid thinking at all, and people who try to avoid thinking, are NOT good critical thinkers.

So, if we want to be good critical thinkers, we have to be very specific and avoid the kind of sloppy over-generalizations that are intended to prevent thinking instead of aiding it.

[Note: The Critical Thinker by Steven Schuster. I hope you will buy and enjoy this simple introductory book about critical thinking. If you click on this link and then buy this, or almost anything else at Amazon, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support!]

**********

If you want to support Anything Smart, please click on the book links in this post and make a purchase. If you buy any of these books through this blog, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for visiting my blog, and thanks for your support!

***

Copyright © 2022 by Joseph Wayne Gadway

Time of the Magicians: Wittgenstein, Benjamin, Cassirer, Heidegger, and the Decade That Reinvented Philosophy

Sunday, November 14, 2021

The Ten Books for General Knowledge Course 2021-2022

With all the projects I am working on, I'm still going to add one more: A survey of all of human knowledge in ten books!

Over the next year I'm going to read 10 books specifically intended to cover as much general knowledge as possible, while still insisting that the books be written in an interesting, enjoyable, and relatively easy-to-understand way.

Most of these books I have read before, but a couple will be new to me.

With thanks, and apologies, to Mr. Dewey Decimal, my own division of all human knowledge goes like this:

  1. Natural Sciences
  2. Social Sciences
  3. Languages
  4. Literatures
  5. Arts
  6. Technologies
  7. Religions
  8. History
  9. Philosophy
  10. General knowledge or mixed works

So, if we read one book in each of these areas then, within a year, we should have vast stores of general knowledge, which is valuable in its own right, and also gives us the critical raw materials for becoming better thinkers.

Let’s go!

---

Book #1: Natural Sciences

Coming of Age in the Milky Way
Timothy Ferris

[Note: Coming of Age in the Milky Way by Timothy Ferris. I hope you will buy and enjoy this brilliant popular science book. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

I will start with the Natural Sciences. The book "Coming of Age in the Milky Way" was published when I was 25 years old. I have read it at least twice and I believe it is the best popular science book I have ever read. If a person were only going to read one science book in their life, I would recommend this one.

The first sentence of the preface explains the author's purpose: "This book purports to tell the story of how, through the workings of science, our species has arrived at its current estimation of the dimensions of cosmic space and time."

How big is the universe?
How old is the universe?
Scientists have found answers to these questions after thousands of years of study.
This book describes how they did it.

In the early chapters of this book Ferris describes what ancient people thought about the universe so we can see how far we have come. In early cities tall buildings were built for priests to climb and study the heavens, because the builders thought a tall building would get the priests significantly closer to the heavenly bodies. At least two ancient thinkers thought the sun was about the size of a shield, and if it was that small, they could not have thought it was too far away. In Ptolemy’s model, which was accepted for more than a thousand years, the entire universe would have fit inside of the Earth’s orbit around the sun.

A lot of the history of Astronomy is just the record of how scientists gradually learned how gigantic the universe really is.

---

Book #2: Social Sciences

The Worldly Philosophers: The Lives, Times, and Ideas of the Great Economic Thinkers Robert L. Heilbroner

[Note: The Worldly Philosophers by Robert L. Heilbroner. I hope you will buy and enjoy this great survey of the classic thinkers in economics. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

---

---

---

---

---

Book #3: Languages

The Elements of Style
William Strunk, Jr.; E.B. White

[Note: The Elements of Style by William Strunk. Revised by E.B. White. I hope you will buy and enjoy this classic book on the proper use of English. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

---

---

---

---

---

Book #4: Literatures

A Little History of Literature
John Sutherland

[Note: A Little History of Literature by John Sutherland. I hope you will buy and enjoy this fantastic survey of literature. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

---

---

---

---

---

---

Book #5: Arts

Civilization
Kenneth Clark

[Note: Civilization by Kenneth Clark. I hope you will buy and enjoy this dazzling study of civilization through great works of art. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

---

---

---

---

---

Book #6: Technologies

The Soul of a New Machine
Tracy Kidder

[Note: The Soul of a New Machine by Tracy Kidder. I hope you will buy and enjoy this masterpiece about the development of a new computer. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

---

---

---

---

---

Book #7: Religions

The World’s Religions
Huston Smith

[Note: The World’s Religions by Huston Smith. I hope you will buy and enjoy this masterpiece about the development of a new computer. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

---

---

---

---

---

Book #8: History

The Penguin History of the World, 6th ed.
J.M. Roberts; Odd Arne Westad

[Note: The Penguin History of the World by J.M. Roberts. Revised by Odd Arne Westad. I hope you will buy and enjoy this sweeping history of the entire world. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

---

---

---

---

---

---

Book #9: Philosophy

The Story of Philosophy
Will Durant

[Note: The Story of Philosophy by Will Durant. I hope you will buy and enjoy this great introduction to some of the most important philosophers in the history of Western Civilization. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

This is the best introductory philosophy book I have ever read. Written by Will Durant, and published in 1926, this book is a classic that everybody should read and anybody can understand.

Durant covers some of the greatest philosophers in the history of Western Civilization including Plato and Aristotle from ancient Greece, Spinoza and Immanuel Kant from early modern Europe, Bertrand Russell and John Dewey from the 20th Century, and several more.

For each philosopher Durant tells us about their lives and the culture they lived in, and then he gives us quick and easy-to-understand introductions to some of their greatest ideas.

Some of these ideas might seem strange to us, but many of them will seem familiar, because these are the thinkers who have created and maintained the foundations of the world we still live in today. The more we know about these philosophers, the better we will understand our own civilization.

This book begins with the three giants of ancient Greek philosophy: Socrates, who believed that if people KNOW what is really good then they will do it, so all we really have to do is teach them; Plato who wrote a whole book, The Republic, about how to create a good society by ensuring that the best people will be its rulers; and Aristotle, who studied everything, and started most of the branches of knowledge that college students still major in today, including, perhaps most importantly, the study of logic itself, so we can have confidence that our thinking is leading us to the truth and not just into a morass of confusion.

---

Book #10: General Knowledge

A History of Knowledge: Past, Present, and Future
Charles Van Doren

[Note: A History of Knowledge by Charles Van Doren. I hope you will buy and enjoy this amazing review of how the human race has come to know the things we do know. If you click on this link to buy it, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

---

---

---

---

---

**********

If you want to support Anything Smart, please click on the book links in this post and make a purchase. This set of ten books will give anyone a huge amount of general knowledge. A good supplement to any education. If you buy any of these books through this blog, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for visiting my blog, and thanks for your support!

***

Copyright © 2021 by Joseph Wayne Gadway

Monday, October 18, 2021

Do Higher Taxes Slow Economic Growth?

Recently I heard someone say that raising taxes will cause the economy to grow more slowly and reducing taxes will cause the economy to grow more quickly.

We can compare tax rates and economic growth for ourselves to see if this is true. This link goes to historical GDP data: https://apps.bea.gov/iTable/iTable.cfm?reqid=19&step=2#reqid=19&step=2&isuri=1&1921=survey. (On the BEA link above, when you get to the web page click on "Section 1," then "Table 1.1.1," then "Modify" to choose the years you want to look at.)

This link goes to historical data on top marginal tax rates: https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/historical-highest-marginal-income-tax-rates.

Using the data from these two web sites let's see what happens to GDP growth as tax rates change.

[Note: The Big Con by Jonathan Chait is an excellent book about supply side economics. If you click on this link to buy it Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

In 1982 Reagan cut the top tax rate from over 69% to 50%.
In 1987 he cut it to 38.5%.
In 1988 it was down to 28%.
Then, in 1991 tax rates started going up again.
So, the Reagan era of low taxes was from 1982-1990.

Looking at the GDP table we can see the GDP grew at an average rate of 3.44% during this period.

If we look at the decade before the Reagan tax cuts it looks like the supply siders might be on to something. From 1972 to 1981 the GDP grew at 3.11% per year. That is good growth, but slower than Reagan's. Does that mean the Reagan tax cuts spurred economic growth?

Let's go back another 10 years.
From 1962 to 1971 the GDP increased at an average of 4.36% per year.
This is much faster than Reagan's growth, and this was long before the Reagan tax cuts.
If the fast economic growth of the 1980s was caused by the Reagan tax cuts, what caused the even faster economic growth of the 1960s when tax rates were much higher?

So, do higher taxes cause slower economic growth or not?
Let's take an extreme case.
From 1951 to 1963 the top marginal tax rate was always over 90%.
If high taxes slow the economy down we should see slow economic growth during this period.
But from 1951 to 1963 the GDP grew at 3.8% per year!
So, we ask again, if the Reagan tax cuts gave us growth of 3.44% why did we have faster growth in this earlier period when the tax rate was much higher?

[Note: The Big Con by Jonathan Chait is an excellent book about supply side economics. If you click on this link to buy it Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

What happened after Reagan?
In 1991 the top tax rate went up from 28% to 31% and in 1993 it went up again to 39.6%.
If higher taxes slow the economy down, we should see that happening in the 1990s as taxes go up.
But from 1991 to 2000 we see that GDP growth was averaging 3.45%.
That is almost exactly the same as what we had under Reagan.

The truth is we had good economic growth under Reagan. But we can find earlier periods when we had even faster growth with higher taxes. And in the period after Reagan, we had equally good growth with higher taxes.

This is just a quick look at changing taxes and changing rates of economic growth.
W could do a more thorough study by looking at other factors such as total taxes rather than top marginal rate.
We could look at a different period of history or a different country than the United States.
We could look at data from individual states or cities....

But what we know for now is, that with the data we looked at here, there does not seem to be any evidence that lower taxes cause the economy to grow faster.

**********

If you want to support Anything Smart, please click on the book links in this post and make a purchase. The Big Con is an excellent book on supply side economics. If you buy it through this blog, Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for visiting my blog, and thanks for your support!

***

Copyright © 2021 by Joseph Wayne Gadway

Sunday, June 28, 2020

Novel: "The Murder of Roger Ackroyd" by Agatha Christie

[Note: The Murder of Roger Ackroyd by Agatha Christie. I hope you will buy and enjoy this masterpiece of a mystery novel. If you click on this link to buy it Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support.]

I just re-read this legendary mystery novel. A plot so diabolical that even when you know who did it you can't believe who did it.

This novel was published in 1926 just five years after Agatha Christie's first book. Even though it came early this story occurs at a time when Hercule Poirot has retired to the countryside where he lives incognito in a village where the people do not know who he is or even how to pronounce his name, where he applies himself to the growing of vegetable marrows which, for American readers, seem to be a sort of squash, and where he misses his friend Captain Hastings who has moved to South America. Fortunately for mystery lovers Poirot is soon called in to solve a murder and he finds a new partner to share the investigation with.

I read this book during the great and horrible coronavirus pandemic of 2020 and every day I felt like the world was going mad. People make outrageously false claims and when you ask them for their evidence they tell you to look it up yourself, which suggests, of course, that they never really had any evidence to begin with. People make outrageous claims and when you show them counter evidence they don't refute it they just call it “fake.” More and more people have no respect for expertise and intelligence and instead they just cheer on bragging and bombast and bullying.

[Note: The Mysterious Affair at Styles by Agatha Christie. This was the first Hercule Poirot mystery published in 1921.]

In a world going mad we need mystery novels like The Murder of Roger Ackroyd and we need heroes like Hercule Poirot to remind us that when you are trying to solve a problem, when you are trying to catch a killer, the only thing that matters is “the little gray cells.” When there is a problem to solve or a killer to catch, then you forget about appearances, you forget about emotions, you forget about what you WANT. The tools you use are sharp observation of the evidence, ruthless logic, and careful testing of theories until the real truth is known and the case is closed.

When a young lady asks Poirot to investigate the murder in this novel he warns her: “... if I go into this, you must understand one thing clearly. I shall go through with it to the end. The good dog, he does not leave the scent, remember! You may wish that, after all, you had left it to the local police.”

[Note: And here is my favorite Hercule Poirot mystery, “The ABC Murders” from 1936. Let me know what you think of it!]

In a world going mad we need mystery novels, and smart detectives, and the brilliant Hercule Poirot with his egg-shaped head and his perfect moustaches who will never stop until he finds the verifiable TRUTH. In a world going mad we need good dogs, who never leave the scent....

**********

If you want to support Anything Smart please click on the book links in this post and make a purchase. Agatha Christie wrote wonderful mysteries and if you buy them through this blog Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for visiting my blog, and thanks for your support!

***

Copyright © 2020 by Joseph Wayne Gadway

Locke: A Biography

Saturday, June 27, 2020

Novel: "The Chamber" by John Grisham

I recently finished this big novel by John Grisham. It came out in 1994, and there was a movie based on it, but somehow I STILL didn't know how the story turned out.

The basic plot involves a young lawyer trying to save his grandfather from the gas chamber for some KKK murders down in Mississippi.

There is SOME mystery in this story, but that's not really the point of the book. The first point of the book is to show us what it is like, to make us FEEL what it is like, to live on death row. The second point of the book is to argue against the death penalty. Grisham tries hard to humanize the people on death row so we will sympathize with them. The basic argument of the book is that killing is wrong: the criminals were wrong to kill and the state is equally wrong to kill them.

[Note: If you click on this link for The Chamber and then buy anything from Amazon then Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for your support!]

The argument that murders and executions are morally equivalent seems very weak to me and is probably false. Most of us do not really believe that a criminal murdering an innocent victim and a government executing a murderer after due process of law are really doing the “same” kind of thing.

But there is another argument in this book, an implied argument based on empathy. This argument might actually be a little stronger in this case. Justice should be blind, right? So, if I would not agree to have my own grandfather executed, how can I justify having someone else's grandfather - or father - or son, executed?

One of the great things novels do is give us a chance to experience things we never will experience in any other way. I think this novel does a good job of giving us a sense of what it is like to live on “The Row,” year after year after year.

As Grisham describes how people live in this strange environment we end up sharing their food - turnip greens and pinto beans and corn bread, we listen intently with them to every sound outside their 6 by 9 foot cells, every foot step, every creak and clang, trying to interpret what is happening in the “outside” world. We count our steps every time we get out for a visitor or a spell in the yard, counting our steps to measure a little extra freedom by how far we can walk without hitting a wall.

[Note: Here is Grisham's first novel. A searing indictment of racism from 1989.]

Most of all we get a sense of the flow of time on the row, slow and dragged out and boring when the execution date is far away, faster and faster and filled with a sickening tension and dread as the date looms closer.

I am against the death penalty but I would not use the arguments made in this book. There are stronger arguments than Grisham deploys here. Nevertheless, what makes this book worth reading is just that it lets us see, and hear, and feel, things that some few other human beings do actually see and hear and feel, and that we, God willing, never will. Unless we read this book.

This novel tells a tragic and horrifying story. I don't feel quite right saying I “enjoyed” it.... It is a dark and painful story. I am not sure that I would want to read this novel twice. But I am happy I read it once. I needed to read it once....

**********

If you want to support Anything Smart please click on the book links in this post and make a purchase. This is an important book and if you buy it through this blog Anything Smart will earn a commission. Thanks for visiting, and thanks for your support!


[Note: And here is a more recent novel by Grisham: "Camino Island" from 2017. Let me know what you think of it!]

***

Copyright © 2020 by Joseph Wayne Gadway